Kohl eyeliner goes on the lash line and the waterline, and it smudges. The finish is soft and deeply pigmented.
Traditional kohl is a mineral powder or lamp soot applied with a stick. Modern pencils bind cosmetic pigments such as iron oxides in wax.
Women and men wear it in South Asia and the Middle East, and across Africa too. Western stores now sell it mainly as a pencil.
Black or not, the shade tells you little about safety. Pure Earth’s October 2024 screening of 60 products labeled kohl, kajal, surma or tiro, bought mainly from online marketplaces, reported that nearly 60 percent of the black samples exceeded the 10 ppm US reference level for lead, against 14 percent of the non-black samples. Its final December 2025 report on 56 products found no such gap. There, 25 of 49 black samples (about 51 percent) and 4 of 7 non-black samples (about 57 percent) exceeded 10 ppm.
What Is Kohl Eyeliner?

Texture is what sets kohl apart. It draws a deeply pigmented, smudgeable line along the lash line and the waterline.
Traditionally it was a powder or paste applied with a stick, though most people now buy a pencil.
Kajal is the South Asian name, prepared in Ayurvedic practice from lamp soot collected on a metal plate. FDA lists surma, al-kahal, tiro, tozali and kwalli as regional names for the same traditional eyeliners.
The word on the label guarantees nothing about the contents. FDA’s archived consumer guidance notes that some eye cosmetics carry the word kohl only to name a shade, not because they contain true kohl.
Next to ordinary eyeliner, kohl is softer, and it goes on the inner rim of the eye as well as along the lashes. Firmer liners stay on the outer lash line.
That placement is the practical definition. Whether it’s a powder or a pencil, or whether it’s called kajal or surma, is a variation on it.
What Is Kohl Eyeliner Made Of?
Lead sulfide (galena) is the usual base of traditional kohl, though some versions use antimony sulfide (stibnite) or soot collected from a burning lamp. Modern kohl pencils drop the mineral base and use cosmetic pigments instead, mainly iron oxides (and, in some brands, carbon black), held in waxes and oils.
Traditional kohl ingredients
FDA reports that lead in traditional kohl usually takes the form of lead sulfide, which sometimes makes up more than half the product’s weight.
Galena is crushed lead sulfide (PbS), the compound most often found when products are analyzed. Stibnite, which is antimony sulfide (Sb2S3), is the mineral many sources name as the classic base. Soot comes from burning ghee or castor oil and forms the base of South Asian kajal. Makers also add compounds of aluminum, iron and zinc, and sometimes camphor and menthol.
Sources disagree on which mineral dominates. Navarro-Tapia and colleagues (International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2021) describe kohl as an antimony-based cosmetic.
A review in Traditional and Integrative Medicine (2022) reports the opposite for the sample it cites. Kohl boxes from Plain Cilicia, Turkey held galena as the main ingredient and no antimony. The review adds that some authors confused the ancient Egyptian name for galena with the Greek and Latin words for antimony, and reported kohl (surma) as antimony instead of lead sulfide.
Going by the names and the ancient stone, you’d guess antimony. Lab analysis of actual products keeps turning up lead sulfide instead.
Ingredients in modern kohl pencils
Pencils swap the mineral for cosmetic colorants held in wax.
Asteri’s Supermassive Black Kohl, for example, lists synthetic wax and carnauba wax with iron oxides (CI 77499) and ferric ferrocyanide (CI 77510) as its colorants, and the brand states the formula leaves out carbon black.
A pencil doesn’t need lead or antimony to go on black. A stable dark pigment and a wax soft enough to smudge will do it.
Kohl Eyeliner Forms: Pot, Stick, Pencil and Cream

You can buy kohl as loose powder in a pot, as paste or kajal sticks, as a pencil, or as a creamy gel-feel pencil.
Powder and paste are the oldest forms. Riesmeier and colleagues (Scientific Reports, 2022) define kohl as a fine powder, plus dried cakes, sticks, stones and pastes made from it.
Pencils are what most people use. They look like an ordinary pencil eyeliner, but the core is softer, so the line glides on the waterline and stays smudgeable under a fingertip.
Retail listings now split the pencil category again. Sephora’s kohl range includes waterproof blendable pencils and a hybrid gel-feel pencil that pairs liquid-liner glide with the smudge of a kohl pencil.
Huda Beauty’s creamy kohl has a gel-like consistency that wears longer.
Color is no longer limited to black. Annabelle’s kohl range alone goes from matte and satin to metallic.
For a first kohl, brown is the gentler start. A makeup artist quoted by Monte Cristo magazine recommends it because the usual black can look too dramatic.
How Kohl Eyeliner Differs From Kajal and Regular Eyeliner

Kohl and kajal are the same sort of soft waterline liner with different regional names, and kajal is also called kohl. Regular eyeliner is firmer and built for a precise line on the outer lash line.
| Product | Base | Texture and finish | Usual placement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional kohl | Mineral powder or soot | Dry, diffuse, smudgy | Waterline and lash line |
| Kajal | Lamp soot in oil or ghee | Creamy, smudgeable | Inner rim and lash line |
| Kohl pencil | Pigment in wax | Soft, smudgeable | Waterline and lash line |
| Regular eyeliner | Liquid, gel or firm pencil | Crisp, defined | Outer lash line |
So softness and placement decide what the product is. The word on the box doesn’t.
Jordan News draws a stricter line, describing kohl as an eye cosmetic that can also darken lashes and brows. Its powder form gives a diffused finish, where eyeliner lays down concentrated pigment.
The same report adds that brands often tag standard colored eyeliner pencils as kohl without the qualities that define it.
Against a liquid eyeliner, kohl stays smudgeable where the liquid dries to a matte finish.
For the waterline and soft, smoky edges, kohl is the one to reach for. Sharp wings are a job for liquid or gel.
Where Kohl Eyeliner Comes From

The oldest known kohl applicator is a stone stick from Yesilova Hoyuk in western Turkey, and it is more than 8,200 years old. Kohl eyeliner comes from the ancient Near East and Egypt.
Zafer Derin of Ege University, the lead archaeologist, says the black residue on the tip is believed to be manganese oxide and has been sent for analysis. He also notes that thick kohl was thought to cut sun glare.
In Egypt, green eye paint was more common than black in predynastic times, and black largely replaced it around the start of the protodynastic and dynastic period. Egyptians used kohl for sacred rites and medicine, not just makeup.
Modern Egyptian-inspired makeup looks still copy that heavy black line, with pencil formulas in place of galena.
Regional names and uses

In South Asia it’s kajal, applied with a fingertip to the inner rim of the lower lid and on the upper lid.
Across the Middle East and North Africa it goes by kohl. People value the look and its reputation as an eye remedy, and the practice has roots in Islamic text.
West Africa has tiro, tozali and kwalli, names FDA links to products from Nigeria.
Did lead make ancient Egyptian kohl protective?
Earlier analysis of 52 samples from makeup containers in the Louvre, cited by Tapsoba and colleagues (Analytical Chemistry, 2010), found four lead-based substances.
Two of them, laurionite and phosgenite, are not found naturally in and around Egypt. Walter’s 1999 Nature paper on cosmetic powders dated 2000 to 1200 BC concluded Egyptians made them by wet chemistry.
There is a case for protection. Tapsoba and colleagues suggest the lead chlorides were made on purpose, because in single-cell tests tiny amounts of lead ions raised nitric oxide release in skin cells, a signal that helps trigger immune defenses. They hedge, though, saying one cannot go as far as to claim a recognized antibacterial purpose.
Against that, the same authors acknowledge that lead’s toxicity has overshadowed any benefit. Walter’s study also examined powders preserved in their original containers, not residue taken from people’s skin.
The Petrie Museum study adds another angle. It analyzed 11 kohl containers and found manganese- and silicon-based minerals besides lead, plus plant and animal ingredients that sometimes made up the main constituent.
Taken together, the three studies describe varied recipes, with lead common but not universal. None measured an effect on a living eye.
Is Kohl Eyeliner Safe?

Not in its traditional form. FDA says traditional kohl commonly contains large amounts of lead and other heavy metals, and links it to lead poisoning, especially in children.
A kohl pencil from a regulated brand with a full ingredient list is a different product, and the word on the label won’t tell you which one you are holding.
FDA’s recommended maximum for lead in externally applied cosmetics is 10 ppm. Pure Earth (2025) tested 56 kohl, kajal and surma eyeliners sold in the US, and 29 exceeded 10 ppm. The highest result was 380,000 ppm (38 percent lead), in a powder labeled lead-free.
Lead from these products can migrate into the user’s body, and poisoning has been documented in both high-income and lower-income countries.
Children carry the most risk. In some cultures parents apply kohl to the eyes of infants and children, and infants of mothers who use it can show elevated blood lead.
Pure Earth also found lead above the FDA level in products sold as baby kajal. Traditional use leaves the powder or cream on the eyelid margin overnight.
The evidence has gaps. Pure Earth says its sample does not represent the whole market. FDA’s page speaks of risk to adults and children but is detailed mainly on children, and Pure Earth says the effect on adult users’ blood lead needs more research.
The documented harm is strongest for children and for loose powders. The adult picture is less settled.
What FDA Rules Say About Kohl Eyeliner
FDA treats kohl, kajal and surma as illegal color additives, so eye cosmetics made with them cannot legally be sold in the United States. FDA notes that they may still arrive, for example in personal luggage, and Pure Earth found them online and in local stores.
The legal basis is the color additive provisions of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, section 201(t). At the border, Import Alert 53-15 covers eye area cosmetics containing kohl, kajal or surma. Its January 26, 1996 revision let districts detain such products without physical examination, including eye area cosmetics that lack an ingredient declaration. The alert has since been revised and renamed, and Pure Earth cites a 2016 version. False claims of FDA approval count as label violations too, and they are cited alongside the unsafe color additive.
The alert has a documented origin. California’s Department of Health Services reported eye pencils and eyeliners containing kohl or kajal that were imported from Germany and labeled as FDA approved.
A later New York State Department of Health report brought powdered surma into scope. The January 26, 1996 revision also added India and Pakistan to the list of import countries.
The 10 ppm figure works differently. FDA published it as draft guidance to industry in December 2016, titled a recommended maximum level for lead in cosmetic lip products and externally applied cosmetics, and the guidance is not legally enforceable. The kohl ban rests on the color additive rule instead.
Enforcement is patchy. Consumer Reports found that the last traditional eyeliner flagged under the color additive alert dated to 2018. Pure Earth bought its samples mainly from online marketplaces and concluded the rules are not being adequately enforced.
Europe handles it differently, with rules that target substances rather than the product name. Navarro-Tapia and colleagues (2021) note that lead was banned from cosmetics while kohl itself was not, and that cosmetics sold in the EU cannot contain lead, antimony, selenium or cadmium, apart from tightly limited unavoidable traces.
Their tests of 12 kohl products from Spanish and German markets led them to call for supervision of traditional kohl before it is distributed in Europe.
How to Choose a Kohl Eyeliner Without Lead
Pick a pencil or cream from a named manufacturer with a full ingredient list, and skip loose powders sold as kohl, kajal or surma.
A lead-free claim does not settle it. In Pure Earth’s 2025 sample, 13 of 17 products labeled lead-free exceeded 10 ppm.
A few things should put you off a listing right away.
- No ingredient list on the pack or listing
- Loose powder labeled kohl, kajal or surma
- A claim of FDA approval
- A marketplace listing where you can’t tell who the manufacturer is
Good signs are easier to spot. An ingredient list that names pigments (iron oxides, CI numbers) and waxes is one, and so is a cream or pencil format.
That authentic-looking pot is the worse buy, honestly. Go with the pencil that has a readable ingredient list.
Cream carries less risk, though not zero. Creams tested significantly lower than powders in the Pure Earth sample, but the authors say the finding needs confirming across the US market.
How to Apply Kohl Eyeliner
Apply kohl with a clean, freshly sharpened pencil along the upper lash line, smudge it with a fingertip, and set it with eyeshadow. Treat the waterline as optional.
- Start with clean, dry lids. Sharpen the pencil thoroughly and remove residue from the tip, or cut a little off the end of a twist-up.
- Draw short strokes along the upper lash line, working between the lash roots.
- Smudge with a fingertip or small brush while the formula is still soft. Kohl’s smudgeable texture is the reason it suits this step.
- Press dark eyeshadow over the line. The makeup artist quoted by Monte Cristo says this blocks natural oils from spreading the pigment.
- Add the lower lash line for more depth, keeping product outside the inner rim.
- Remove all of it before bed.
Should kohl go on the waterline?
Within five minutes, 15 to 30 percent more eyeliner particles moved into the tear film when pencil went inside the lash line than outside it (Ng and colleagues, Eye & Contact Lens, 2015).
By two hours the contamination was negligible. The pilot used a glitter pencil on three volunteers, so treat the size of the effect as a rough guide.
The inner rim does give the deepest, smokiest definition, and it is how kohl has always been worn. Ohio State’s Wexner Medical Center, though, says waterline makeup is more likely to block the meibomian oil glands and adds more cosmetic to the tear film.
Keep the upper lash line for daily wear and save the waterline for occasions, if you use it at all.
Tightlining the upper waterline gives the densest lash look and carries the same trade-off. A guide to tightlining your eyes covers the technique.
What goes wrong when you apply kohl eyeliner
Oily lids smudge it into the crease. Waxes and oils can stick to contact lenses and build up if used for more than one day. Old product can harbor bacteria, since previous studies show old eye makeup can do that. And a dull or contaminated tip will irritate.
Runs and smears have their own fixes, covered in a guide on how to stop eyeliner from running.
Ohio State advises discarding liquid or creamy eye makeup after three months, which covers cream kohl.
Kohl Eyeliner FAQ
Which kohl eyeliner is best?
Go for a pencil or cream with a complete ingredient list and a named manufacturer. Pure Earth (2025) found creams tested significantly lower in lead than powders, so a retail kohl pencil beats an imported pot.
Is kohl eyeliner safe for babies and children?
No. FDA links traditional kohl to lead poisoning, especially in children, and urges people to stop using lead-contaminated kohl.
Anyone who has used it on a child, or while pregnant or nursing, should ask a healthcare provider about lead testing.
Can you wear kohl eyeliner with contact lenses?
Yes, with more care. Ohio State’s Wexner Medical Center says contact lens wearers can face a higher risk of irritation and infection when makeup hygiene is poor.
Keep the product off the inner rim and sharpen the pencil before each use. Take everything off before bed.
Does kohl eyeliner irritate sensitive or dry eyes?
It can. Makeup that enters the tear film causes discomfort for people with sensitive or dry eyes, and dry eyes have fewer tears to dilute it.
Apply kohl outside the lash line, and see an eye doctor if redness or stinging continues.
Is kohl eyeliner waterproof?
Not by default. The Indian brand Forest Essentials says its ghee and castor oil kajal is not fully smudge proof.
Some pencils carry a waterproof formula, and the label decides, not the word kohl. Those formulas need more than water to come off, which a guide to removing waterproof makeup covers.
Can kohl eyeliner make a winged look?
Yes, a soft one. Glide kohl along the upper lash line, then spread it outward with a fingertip into a smudged cat eye.
A crisp, sharp wing still calls for gel or liquid liner.
How do you remove kohl eyeliner?
Hold a cotton pad soaked in eye makeup remover on the closed lid for a few seconds, then wipe outward. Eyeliner commonly contains waxes and oils, plus silicones, so water alone leaves residue on the lash line.
A step-by-step guide to removing eye makeup covers the full routine.
What to Do If You Already Use Traditional Kohl
Traditional kohl eyeliner should come off the eyelid the same day, because lead exposure continues for as long as the product stays on the skin.
Stop using it. Children and pregnant or nursing users should get tested, and a kohl pencil that lists its ingredients can take its place.
Between the last 2018 alert flag and Pure Earth’s purchases from June 2024 to March 2025, contaminated kohl stayed on sale, so an unflagged listing is not a cleared one.
One trade-off is that a pencil gives a smudged line rather than the dry, diffuse finish of loose powder.
This advice changes if FDA converts the 10 ppm guidance into a binding limit. On the lead-in-cosmetics page last updated February 25, 2022, it remains nonbinding guidance.
With a safe pencil in hand, a guide to smokey eye makeup puts that smudgeable texture to work.
- How to Apply NARS Foundation Like a Pro - November 10, 2026
- How to Do Makeup for a Wedding That Lasts - November 8, 2026
- How to Store Makeup to Keep It Fresh - November 7, 2026